Shelter Island, NY Homes for Sale and Real Estate

Find Shelter Island homes for sale and view Shelter Island, New York real estate listings. Search our complete database of Shelter Island, NY real estate listings for houses, condos, land, and building lots. Features include photos, property description, beds, baths, maps and virtual tours. Use Homes and Land to find the realty listing information you need to buy or sell a home in Shelter Island.

FEATURED LISTING

$860,000 Offered By: Janalyn Travis-Messer Griffing & Collins Real Estate	Save View Request More Info

FEATURED LISTING

$999,000 Offered By: Georgiana B Ketcham Georgiana B. Ketcham R.E.	Save View Request More Info

[Close]

$2,200,000 Shelter Island, NY 11964 5 bed, 1 full ba Offered By: Janalyn Travis-Messer Griffing & Collins Real Estate Save \| View	$1,895,000 Shelter Island, NY 4 bed, 3 full ba, 1 half ba Offered By: Joan H Bischoff Van Heemskerck Town & Country Real Estate - Southold Save \| View	$1,859,000 Shelter Island, NY 4 bed, 4 full ba Offered By: George Pfriender George Pfriender LLC Save \| View
$1,795,000 Shelter Island, NY 4 bed, 3 full ba, 1 half ba Offered By: George Pfriender George Pfriender LLC Save \| View	$1,795,000 Shelter Island, NY 11964 4 bed, 3 full ba, 1 half ba Offered By: Joan H Bischoff Van Heemskerck Town & Country Real Estate - Southold Save \| View	$1,190,000 Shelter Island, NY 11964 5 bed Offered By: Janalyn Travis-Messer Griffing & Collins Real Estate Save \| View

Page 2 Of 6

[Close]

Visit Our Local Magazines

View Real Estate Resources

Our Local Magazine Network
Homes of Eastern Long Island View Website View Online Magazine Advertise Order this Magazine Homes of the Hamptons View Website View Online Magazine Advertise Order this Magazine

Local Real Estate Resources

Shelter Island Real Estate Services

Search Assistant

Start New Search

Search New City, State or ZIP
Search New City, Prov. or Postal Code

Beds

Baths

Min $

Max $

32 Listings in
Shelter Island, NY

Save This Search

Refine Search

Price Range

Beds & Baths

Virtual Tours

Video Tours / Virtual Tours

Property Type

Select Additional Areas

More Criteria

Find local plumbers, electricians, contractors, and more.

$2,200,000 Shelter Island, NY 11964 5 bed, 1 full ba Offered By: Janalyn Travis-Messer Griffing & Collins Real Estate Save \| View	$1,895,000 Shelter Island, NY 4 bed, 3 full ba, 1 half ba Offered By: Joan H Bischoff Van Heemskerck Town & Country Real Estate - Southold Save \| View	$1,859,000 Shelter Island, NY 4 bed, 4 full ba Offered By: George Pfriender George Pfriender LLC Save \| View
$1,795,000 Shelter Island, NY 4 bed, 3 full ba, 1 half ba Offered By: George Pfriender George Pfriender LLC Save \| View	$1,795,000 Shelter Island, NY 11964 4 bed, 3 full ba, 1 half ba Offered By: Joan H Bischoff Van Heemskerck Town & Country Real Estate - Southold Save \| View	$1,190,000 Shelter Island, NY 11964 5 bed Offered By: Janalyn Travis-Messer Griffing & Collins Real Estate Save \| View

Shelter Island, NY Homes for Sale and Real Estate

Shelter Island Real Estate Services

Selling Your Home?

Buying A New Home?

Home Improvement Professionals

About Homes & Land