Add to Favorites Add to Favorites
Add to Favorites
For Sale


5561 State Route 28
Eagle Bay, NY 13331

Sqft 2,414 sqft
The Bay Caf sits right on Rt 28 in Eagle Bay near the snowmobile crossing so it is a perfect location for riders to come in to eat. In the summer, the Cafe served breakfast and lunch with some dinner specials and pizza takeout. The building has been totally renovated and is fully spray foam insulated, new metal roof, new siding, a new well, new septic system, new grease trap, and is fully equipped for a breakfast and luncheon menu. Furnishings and equipment are included. The authentic, wood fired pizza oven adds a dimension of serving freshly baked pizza. Upstairs is totally finished with an area that was used for retail gifts and decorative accessories. The display pieces are included and there is a small amount of inventory which can be purchased separately. The covered porch on the side can be used for additional seating in warm weather. Here is an opportunity to walk in the door and start operating in this lovely, almost new setting. Read More

Market Status
Last Updated
July 24, 2021

Property Type
Commercial Property
Year Built
Handicapped Access
Central Air
Exterior Construction
Property Type
Commercial; Commercial

Local Market Conditions

There are currently 145 properties for sale in the Herkimer County, NY area with the average listing price of $322,884. This represents an increase of +1.8% over the previous week. The 4 bedroom homes saw the largest increase in the average listing price over the previous week with a +6.5% increase. To learn more about the Herkimer County, NY area, contact a local expert!

Market Snapshot for Herkimer County, NY

Avg. Listing Price


Wk ending Jul 24









Average Listing Price for Herkimer County, NY
No. BedroomsNo. Beds Week Ending
(Jul 24)
w-o-w Week Ending
(Jul 17)
Week Ending
(Jul 10)
Week Ending
(Jul 3)
All PropertiesAll $322,884 +1.8% $317,219 $316,097 $313,913
1 bedroom1 BR $199,000 +0.0% $199,000 $199,000 $149,450
2 bedrooms2 BR $188,626 +0.4% $187,833 $192,092 $195,420
3 bedrooms3 BR $221,721 +0.7% $220,198 $205,192 $206,124
4 bedrooms4 BR $509,491 +6.5% $478,328 $469,088 $481,152

Home loan
Need a Home Loan?
Take the first step to secure financing for your home.

Listing Provided By:

Dawn W. Timm

Timm Associates Sotheby's International Realty

This $372,000 Commercial Property at 5561 State Route 28 in Eagle Bay, NY is offered by Dawn W. Timm. This $372,000 Commercial Property, located in the 13331 zip code, has the following property features: Mountain View, View, Fireplace, Exterior Construction. This 5561 State Route 28 Commercial Property is listed under MLS listing number 173536 and has a listing price of $372,000. You can find more of Dawn W. Timm's listings by browsing Dawn W. Timm homes for sale at, or even more Eagle Bay homes for sale here.

Data Provided by Adirondack Champlain Valley MLS