Add to Favorites Add to Favorites
Add to Favorites
For Sale


46 Martha Street
Ellicottville, NY 14731

Bed 4 br
Bathroom 2.5 ba
Sqft 4,000 sqft
MUST SEE! Fully renovated 1850's church boasts soaring cathedral ceilings w/ ceiling fans, the original refinished HW floors, w/ a stunning custom chef's kitchen featuring a wolf stove, sub-zero fridge, Bosch dishwasher & a Kohler Farmhouse style sink. Stamped copper ceiling & antique bar stools at the Island/Breakfast Bar. Ample dinning space w/a huge wooden dining room table with church pew benches. This unique home features 4 bedrooms (plus a bunk room w/ 3 bunks), 2.5 bath with a grand bathroom sink you just must see to believe. Radiant heated floors on both floors, and a wood burning stove will be sure to keep you warm while you enjoy the great room, surrounded by beautiful original stain glass windows & wainscoting. Beautiful master bedroom & bath, as well as first floor laundry! Spiral staircases lead you to 2 lofts w/original Globe lighting and Original Bell tower (the bell still works!) There is an exterior shed for extra storage & a fenced back yard, as well as a concrete driveway and heated sidewalks! Walk to all the amenities in town & the HoliMont Cascade chairlift. Square Footage does not match country records, as per owners measurements, it is 4,000 sq. ft. Read More

Market Status
Last Updated
August 2, 2021

Property Type
Single Family Home
Year Built
4 BR
2 full BA; 1 ½BA
Cooling System
Window Unit(s) A/C
Heating System
Fireplace; Hot Water; Radiant
Heating Fuel
Natural Gas
Exterior Construction
Ceiling Fan
Carpet; Hardwood; Tile
Property Type
Residential; Single Family Detached
Entryway / Foyer
Living Room
Family Room
Great Room
Bonus Room
Additional Areas
Bedroom; Bedroom; Bedroom; Bedroom; Full Bath; Full Bath; Half Bath; Loft
Laundry Room
Additional Features
Ellicottville Elementary,Ellicottville; Ellicottville,Lawn,Ellicottville Middle High
Additional Features
Ellicottville Elementary,Lawn,Ellicottville; Ellicottville,Ellicottville Middle High
Additional Features
Ellicottville Middle High,Ellicottville Elementary,Ellicottville; Ellicottville,Lawn
Additional Features
Ellicottville Middle High,Ellicottville Elementary,Lawn,Ellicottville; Ellicottville
Additional Features
Ellicottville Middle High,Ellicottville; Ellicottville,Ellicottville Elementary,Lawn
Additional Features
Ellicottville; Ellicottville,Ellicottville Middle High,Ellicottville Elementary,Lawn
Additional Features
Ellicottville; Ellicottville,Ellicottville Middle High,Lawn,Ellicottville Elementary
Additional Features
Ellicottville; Ellicottville,Lawn,Ellicottville Elementary,Ellicottville Middle High
Additional Features
Ellicottville; Ellicottville,Lawn,Ellicottville Middle High,Ellicottville Elementary
Additional Features
Lawn,Ellicottville; Ellicottville,Ellicottville Elementary,Ellicottville Middle High

Local Market Conditions

There are currently 60 properties for sale in the Ellicottville, NY area with the average listing price of $240,385. This represents an increase of +4.1% over the previous week. To learn more about the Ellicottville, NY area, contact a local expert!

Market Snapshot for Ellicottville, NY

Avg. Listing Price


Wk ending Jul 31









Average Listing Price for Ellicottville, NY
No. BedroomsNo. Beds Week Ending
(Jul 31)
w-o-w Week Ending
(Jul 24)
Week Ending
(Jul 17)
Week Ending
(Jul 10)
All PropertiesAll $240,385 +4.1% $230,901 $232,875 $232,055
1 bedroom1 BR $80,073 +0.0% $80,073 $80,073 $86,273
2 bedrooms2 BR $134,828 +0.0% $134,828 $125,939 $124,042
3 bedrooms3 BR $346,156 +0.0% $346,156 $361,557 $361,557
4 bedrooms4 BR $518,450 +0.0% $518,450 $532,673 $532,673

Home loan
Need a Home Loan?
Take the first step to secure financing for your home.

Listing Provided By:

David A Blanchard

Keller WilliamsRealtyLancaster

This $749,900 Single Family Home at 46 Martha Street in Ellicottville, NY is presented by David A Blanchard. This $749,900 Single Family Home, located in the 14731 zip code, has the following property features: Refrigerator, Heating System, Ellicottville; Ellicottville,Ellicottville Middle High,Ellicottville Elementary,Lawn, Ellicottville Elementary,Ellicottville; Ellicottville,Lawn,Ellicottville Middle High. This 46 Martha Street Single Family Home is listed under MLS listing number B1334613, has 4 beds, 3 baths, and has a listing price of $749,900. You can find more Ellicottville homes for sale here.

Data Provided by Western New York Real Estate Information Services

More Information for this listing