Browse through our real estate listings in Shelter Island, NY, save your "favorite" properties to your account and sort listings by price, property types, bedrooms, bathrooms and more. Homes & Land® offers in-depth property details on home listings in Shelter Island. Select a listing from the available Shelter Island properties to browse photos, watch virtual tours and review up-to-date market research and local market conditions in and around Shelter Island, NY, from Homes & Land®