Add to Favorites Add to Favorites
Share Share
Add to Favorites
For Sale


40B Stearns Point Road
Shelter Island, NY 11964

Bed 7 br
Bathroom 6.5 ba
Sqft 5,793 sqft
This soaring light filled home blends gently onto a majestic waterfront bluff, one of the highest points on Shelter Island centrally located above Crescent Beach - a perfect viewing spot for the annual Shelter Island Fireworks! Surrounded by almost four acres of wooded privacy, the property offers sweeping water views across the North Fork and beyond to the Connecticut shoreline, with glorious year round sunsets. Designed by architect Michael Haverland, the residence is a hybrid of a 1925 Shelter Island traditional beach house, juxtaposed perfectly with a 3400 square foot modern addition, for a total of over 6000 square feet of living space. Two elegant wings come together, their pitched roof lines and mullioned walls of glass blending seamlessly with the style of the original beach house. Delicate steel window frames are detailed as thin as possible, providing an abundance of natural light, allowing magnificent water views. The northwest facing bedroom wing provides separation and privacy from the rest of the house. The master bedroom suite's exposed steel beams support a vaulted ceiling with a full window wall of endless views. A second bedroom suite below with floor to ceiling windows offers similar stunning vistas. Both master and guest suites have attached dressing rooms. Each features a generous size stone and tiled bathroom complete with a luxurious soaking tub, glass enclosed shower and oversized wall hung double sinks. The living room wing faces north and west, also with exposed structural steel columns and beams serving as a counterpoint to a 23' gabled wall of glass. Polished limestone flooring balances with a two story fieldstone fireplace, customized with an inset flat screen for relaxing evening enjoyment. An inviting entrance foyer greets visitors with views through to the water, and serves to transition the modern to the original house, which has been extensively renovated.The 1925 living and dining room have been combined into an exp Read More

Market Status
Last Updated
May 10, 2021

Property Type
Single Family Home
Year Built
7 BR
6 full BA; 1 ½BA
Central Air
4 spaces
Property Type
Residential; Single Family Detached
Entryway / Foyer
Living Room
Dining Room
Media Room / Home Theater
Additional Areas
Bedroom; Bedroom; Bedroom; Bedroom; Bedroom; Bedroom; Bedroom; Full Bath; Full Bath; Full Bath; Full Bath; Full Bath; Full Bath; Half Bath

Local Market Conditions

There are currently 11 properties for sale in the Shelter Island, NY area with the average listing price of $3,791,027. This represents a decrease of -4.5% over the previous week. To learn more about the Shelter Island, NY area, contact a local expert!

Market Snapshot for Shelter Island, NY

Avg. Listing Price


Wk ending May 8








Average Listing Price for Shelter Island, NY
No. BedroomsNo. Beds Week Ending
(May 8)
w-o-w Week Ending
(May 1)
Week Ending
(Apr 24)
Week Ending
(Apr 17)
All PropertiesAll $3,791,027 -4.5% $3,970,130 $3,841,692 $3,645,936
1 bedroom1 BR - +0.0% - $449,000 $449,000
2 bedrooms2 BR - +0.0% - - -
3 bedrooms3 BR $1,643,150 +27.7% $1,286,300 $1,286,300 $1,286,300
4 bedrooms4 BR $4,321,667 +0.0% $4,321,667 $4,321,667 $3,485,000

Home loan
Need a Home Loan?
Take the first step to secure financing for your home.
This $7,750,000 Single Family Home at 40B Stearns Point Road in Shelter Island, NY is presented by John Catrambone and has been on the market for 109 days. This $7,750,000 Single Family Home, located in the 11964 zip code, has the following property features: Refrigerator, Kitchen, Basement, Living Room. This 40B Stearns Point Road Single Family Home, located in Suffolk County , is listed under MLS listing number 10965848, has 7 beds, 7 baths, and has a listing price of $7,750,000. You can find more Shelter Island homes for sale here.

Data Provided by NY State MLS

More Information for this listing

Request More Information