Add to Favorites Add to Favorites
Add to Favorites
For Sale


8 Cobbetts Lane
Shelter Island, NY 11964

Bed 4 br
Bathroom 5.5 ba
Sqft 6,000 sqft
From Wall Street Journal "House of the Day" developers Mike & Kerry Gaynor, comes a brand-new country estate set on two acres and surrounded by 400 acres of forever protected farmland. Their incredibly refreshing and elegant approach to this luxury property is unmatched anywhere in the Hamptons market today. The compound includes a newly constructed 6,000 sq. ft. Federal Style farmhouse, a heavy timber barn, a pool house, a fire barn, and a two-car garage. The beautifully crafted home features shiplap paneling and white oak flooring throughout. Enter the elegant home through the gracious entry foyer with a custom Dutch front door giving way to the formal living room and sunroom both with wood burning fireplaces, an intimate dining room and a wood paneled office. The sunlit kitchen features a Calcutta marble island and countertops, custom cabinetry, farmhouse sink, a Wolf double oven, and two Sub-Zero refrigerators. The open style kitchen and family room make this the heart of the house, with French doors leading out to a covered porch-perfect for dining outdoors. The mudroom features custom barn doors, granite counter tops and honed marble flooring. A gracious staircase leads to the second level which features a spectacular 1,020 sq. ft. primary bedroom with a cathedral ceiling, an en-suite spa like bath that features marble flooring, a soaking tub, a steam shower with multiple Waterworks shower heads and a Carrara marble bench. The custom double vanities feature honed Carrara countertops as well as Waterworks sinks and faucets. The primary suite also features a walk-in closet, breakfast/wet bar, and laundry room. A large private deck overlooking the pastoral grounds complete the primary suite. The second floor also features an en-suite guest bedroom. The sundrenched lower level offers a gracious walk-out guest suite with a living room/entertaining area including a wet bar and two Sub-Zero refrigerators. The en-suite bedroom is separated from the living ro Read More

Market Status
Last Updated
July 1, 2022

Property Type
Single Family Home
Year Built
4 BR
4 full BA; 3 ½BA
Central Air
Exterior Construction
Cedar Siding; Wood Siding
Property Type
Residential; Single Family Detached
Entryway / Foyer
Living Room
Dining Room
Family Room
Media Room / Home Theater
Additional Areas
Bedroom; Bedroom; Bedroom; Bedroom; Den; Full Bath; Full Bath; Full Bath; Full Bath; Half Bath; Half Bath; Half Bath

Local Market Conditions

There are currently 2,624 properties for sale in the Suffolk County, NY area with the average listing price of $1,631,971. This represents an increase of +1.1% over the previous week. The 1 bedroom homes saw the largest increase in the average listing price over the previous week with a +9.3% increase. To learn more about the Suffolk County, NY area, contact a local expert!

Market Snapshot for Suffolk County, NY

Avg. Listing Price


Wk ending Jul 2








Average Listing Price for Suffolk County, NY
No. BedroomsNo. Beds Week Ending
(Jul 2)
w-o-w Week Ending
(Jun 25)
Week Ending
(Jun 18)
Week Ending
(Jun 11)
All PropertiesAll $1,631,971 +1.1% $1,613,713 $1,666,404 $1,649,500
1 bedroom1 BR $640,427 +9.3% $585,785 $354,764 $385,900
2 bedrooms2 BR $795,976 +0.9% $788,936 $801,693 $823,934
3 bedrooms3 BR $770,912 +1.0% $763,325 $772,271 $767,520
4 bedrooms4 BR $1,167,658 -0.3% $1,171,185 $1,211,602 $1,210,026

Home loan
Need a Home Loan?
Take the first step to secure financing for your home.

Listing Provided By:

Jennifer Wilson

Saunders & Associates - East Hampton Office

This $13,750,000 Single Family Home at 8 Cobbetts Lane in Shelter Island, NY is offered by Jennifer Wilson. This $13,750,000 Single Family Home, located in the 11964 zip code, has the following property features: Living Room, Taxes, Exterior Construction, Additional Areas. This 8 Cobbetts Lane Single Family Home is listed under MLS listing number 11071708, has 4 beds, 7 baths, and has a listing price of $13,750,000. You can find more Shelter Island homes for sale here.

Copyright © 2022 NY State MLS. All rights reserved. All information provided by the listing agent/broker is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed and should be independently verified.

More Information for this listing