Add to Favorites Add to Favorites
Share Share
Add to Favorites
For Sale


Cartwright Manor House
Shelter Island, NY 11964

Bed 4 br
Bathroom 3 ba
Sqft 2,000 sqft
Own a part of Shelter Island history with this 1816 home, built as the principal residence on the estate of the prolific whaling family, the Cartwrights. This distinctive 19th Century 4-bedroom, 3 full bath cedar shake home comes with a private road as part of an over 1.8 acres estate and200 feet of private coastline. Both the first and second floors boast master bedrooms. All bathrooms have a standing shower and a separate bathtub. The first-floor master bathroom features beautiful Carrera marble floor tiles and walls, with "his and her" sinks, and the second-floor master has a clawfoot soaking tub overlooking the harbor. Spectacular views of Coecles Harbor can be seen from almost every room in the house, and an elevated panoramic view of the harbor from the Juliet balcony off the upstairs master. Sit in the beautiful Florida room and watch the sailboats come into the nearby marina. A boater's dream with a private 100' dock plus an added floating dock sheltered in the harbor. As the new owner, you will also have water rights, so a mooring can be placed deeper in the water for larger boats, rights to build a pool, pool house, art studio, barn, or tennis courts. Property is one of the few waterfront estates that is in Zone C. Potential buyers should do their own research into C zone uses though the Town of Shelter Island. This house has withstood the test of time and kept generations of the Cartwright family safely sheltered from all of mother nature's challenges. Please contact us to arrange a tour and make this breathtaking 1816 waterfront estate your families perfect safe haven. Read More

Market Status
Last Updated
June 16, 2021

Property Type
Single Family Home
Year Built
4 BR
3 full BA
Heating System
Property Type
Entryway / Foyer
Living Room
Additional Areas
Bedroom; Bedroom; Bedroom; Bedroom; Full Bath; Full Bath; Full Bath

Local Market Conditions

There are currently 9 properties for sale in the Shelter Island, NY area with the average listing price of $4,369,444. This represents an increase of +7.6% over the previous week. The 3 bedroom homes saw the largest increase in the average listing price over the previous week with a +21.7% increase. To learn more about the Shelter Island, NY area, contact a local expert!

Market Snapshot for Shelter Island, NY

Avg. Listing Price


Wk ending Jun 19








Average Listing Price for Shelter Island, NY
No. BedroomsNo. Beds Week Ending
(Jun 19)
w-o-w Week Ending
(Jun 12)
Week Ending
(Jun 5)
Week Ending
(May 29)
All PropertiesAll $4,369,444 +7.6% $4,061,130 $4,061,130 $4,282,391
1 bedroom1 BR - +0.0% - - -
2 bedrooms2 BR - +0.0% - - -
3 bedrooms3 BR $1,999,999 +21.7% $1,643,150 $1,643,150 $1,643,150
4 bedrooms4 BR $4,875,000 +0.0% $4,875,000 $4,875,000 $4,456,667

Home loan
Need a Home Loan?
Take the first step to secure financing for your home.

Listing Provided By:

Mark Liberman

This $7,250,000 Single Family Home at Cartwright Manor House in Shelter Island, NY is presented by Mark Liberman. This $7,250,000 Single Family Home, located in the 11964 zip code, has the following property features: Living Room, Refrigerator, Heating System, Stories. This Cartwright Manor House Single Family Home is listed under MLS listing number 10945597, has 4 beds, 3 baths, and has a listing price of $7,250,000. You can find more Shelter Island homes for sale here.

Data Provided by NY State MLS

More Information for this listing

Request More Information